The suspension of natural gas service to Poland and Bulgaria will not do immediate damage to the European economy, but Europe could face a sharp slowdown of growth if the cutoff spreads to other countries – or if Europe imposes an embargo on Russian gas, economists said. .
Russia’s war on Ukraine is already rippling through Europe, lashing energy prices and hurting manufacturers just as the bloc was recovering from a pandemic-induced recession. The International Monetary Fund last week cut its 2022 forecast for the countries that use the euro to 2.8 percent, from a 3.9 percent estimate in January, with Germany, the largest economy, taking a big hit.
The euro fell Wednesday below $ 1.06 for the first time in five years on rising concerns about energy security and a slowdown in European growth. The currency has slumped nearly 4 percent against the US dollar in April alone.
The action this week by Gazprom, Russia’s oil monopoly, to turn off the gas taps to two European Union nations was unlikely to tip Europe into a fresh recession immediately. This is in part because Europe “still has many diplomatic and fiscal policy responses available” to combat one, said Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS, in a note to clients.
But the spectrum of an outright energy war – including a potential European embargo on Russian gas and oil – is looming at a vulnerable time. European companies are already facing higher energy costs, which are threatening profit margins and squeezing consumers’ purchasing power, analysts said.
The European Union has been drafting plans for an embargo on Russian oil but made no mention of it in the hours after Gazprom’s cutoff. Europe put in place a ban on Russian coal this month. And while Germany in particular has resisted embargoes on Russian oil or gas because of the outsize costs to its industry, officials have recently recognized.
“This is a thinly veiled threat to Germany— Berlin is currently weighing how far it and the EU can go in sanctioning Russian energy exports, and Russian threats are directed to change its calculus,” said Jonathan Hackenbroich, a policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations.
Still, a full gas cutoff for Germany “would have dire consequences for the German and European economies,” he added. “Factories would have to curb production or even close. Some key industries could be lost forever, and it is in fact hard to assess the full range of consequences. But Russia is also highly dependent on revenue from energy exports as they represent its last big lifeline, ”Mr. Hackenbroich said.
An embargo on Russian energy is likely to trigger a European recession, and high inflation “would become even higher inflation,” said Carsten Brzeski, global head of research at ING Bank.
“All of this is clearly negative for the short-term outlook,” he said. “But to make it worse, high energy and commodity prices and disrupted supply chains will all put Europe’s international competitiveness at risk.”
Germany’s five leading economic research institutes said this month that a full energy embargo, were one to be enacted immediately, would reduce annual economic growth in the European Union this year and the next by a cumulative 3 percent, while raising inflation by roughly 1 percentage point in both years.
That is because natural gas would probably have to be rationed as of the start of next year, and parts of the European industry “would then have to be switched off for four months to enable households to still heat their homes during the cold season,” Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank, said.
He said that it was “at least conceivable” that rationing could begin even earlier in the event of an immediate Russian gas cutoff.
“My best guess remains that the damage to European growth would be quite serious.” Schmieding said. “Whether or not it would be a price worth paying to constrain Russia’s ability to sustain a long war is ultimately a political judgment that goes well beyond a mere economic calculus.”